SUMMARY
Background. There is no consensus on the optimal treatment of displaced proximal humeral fractures. The purpose of this prospective study was to present a 5-year follow-up of conservative treatment of proximal humeral fractures as compared to surgical treatment (ORIF).
Materials and methods. Fifty consecutive patients with a proximal humeral fracture (Neer types 2, 3, 4; hertel types 3 through 8) were enrolled in this study and randomized in two groups: conservative treatment (group A) and open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) with a plate (group B). Twenty patients of group A and 15 patients of group B were available for the final follow-up. All patients were clinically evaluated at 1, 3, and 12 months, and at final follow-up with physical and radiological examination, functional scores (Constant-Murley, quick DASH, ASES, SF-12), and overall satisfaction (from 1 to 4).
Results. The groups were homogeneous with regard to demographic data and radiological classifications of fractures. At the final follow-up (5.21 ± 1.30 years), the Constant-Murley score was 82.0 ± 7.6 (group A) and 87.0 ± 5.4 (group B) (n.s.); quick-
DASH was 8.7 ± 4.3 (group A) and 5.4 ± 0.37 (group B) (n.s.); ASES was 83.7 ± 7.0 (group A) and 96.1 ± 1.0 (group B) (p = 0.003); and SF-12 was 88.2 ± 5.9 (group A) and 90.1 ± 5 .7 (group B) (n.s.). Eighty-five percent of patients in group A and 100% in group B were satisfied or very satisfied with their results (n.s.). One patient in group B reported wound dehiscence, which was treated with medical therapy.
Conclusions. Conservative treatment in proximal humeral fractures provides similar results in functional and symptom-related scores after 5 years, compared to ORIF. Indications
for ORIF should be reserved only for patients with high functional demand.
Comparison between Conservative and Surgical Treatment in Proximal Humeral Fractures. A Prospective Randomized Study with 5-Years Follow-Up
M. Guzzini, R. M. Lanzetti, G. Princi, M. Spoliti, M. C. Moretti, G. Koverech, A. P. Vadalà, D. Mazza, F. Cannari, D. Topa, A. Ferretti
Original Article, 240-245
Keywords: clinical outcomes, fracture., humerus, nonoperative treatment, ORIF, plate, radiological outcomes,
Table of Content: Vol. 11 (No.2) 2021 April/June
-
The Role of Fibro-Adipogenic Progenitors in Musculoskeletal Disease
G. Kaur, M. R. Davies, X. Liu, B. T. FeeleyReview, 201-214 -
Effects of Traditional Srichiangmai dance on Balance and Mobility in the Elderly
M. Buransri, Y. PhanphengOriginal Article, 215-222 -
Natural History of Patients with Acute Proximal Biceps Tendon Rupture
D. P. Axibal, N. C. Yeatts, A. J. Rao, K. R. Muña, I. S. Hong, P. M. Connor, J. E. Fleischli, D. P. Piasecki, B. M. Saltzman, N. HamidOriginal Article, 223-230 -
Dominant vs Nondominant Arm in Surgical Repair of Distal Biceps Tendon Rupture. A Case-Control Series of Isotonic Muscle Strength Evaluation
F. Calderazzi, F. Addevico, C. Galavotti, A. Nosenzo, M. Menozzi, A. Garzia, C. CostantinoOriginal Article, 231-239 -
Comparison between Conservative and Surgical Treatment in Proximal Humeral Fractures. A Prospective Randomized Study with 5-Years Follow-Up
M. Guzzini, R. M. Lanzetti, G. Princi, M. Spoliti, M. C. Moretti, G. Koverech, A. P. Vadalà, D. Mazza, F. Cannari, D. Topa, A. FerrettiOriginal Article, 240-245 -
Can Supraspinatus Tears Contribute to Acquired Subcoracoid Impingement? A Radiological Study of Anterosuperior Cuff Tears
M. J. Leite, A. R. Pinho, M. C. Sá, M. R. Silva, J. M. Almeida, A. N. Sousa, J. M. TorresReview, 246-250 -
The Effectiveness of Trigger Point Injection Plus Kinesio Taping in Myofascial Pain Syndrome: a Randomized, Sham-Controlled Clinical Trial
E. YılmazOriginal Article, 251-258 -
Cross-Cultural Adaptation and Measurement Properties of the Brazilian Portuguese Version of Two Scales Which Measure Function and Disability in People with Achilles Tendinopathy
Y. A. Bandeira Murakawa, S. F. Chaves Coêlho Ferreira, M. L. Azevedo Tavares, M. Almeida Bezerra, R. Ribeiro de OliveiraOriginal Article, 259-264 -
TGF-ß1 Expression in Contractured Achilles Tendon among Diabetic Foot Patients: a Semi-Quantitative Study
R. A. Primadhi, H. Gunawan, S. Rachmayati, H. N. RasyidOriginal Article, 265-272 -
Anterior Tibial Tendon Transfer for Treatment of Recurrent Congenital Clubfoot Initially Treated According to Ponseti Method. Update and Systematic Review Of Literature
V. De Luna, A. Caterini, G. Gorgolini, M. Marsiolo, F. De Maio, P. FarsettiReview, 273-280 -
An adaptive Model of Achilles Tendon Mechanical Properties during Adolescence: Effect of Sex
G. Chalatzoglidis, A. J. Blazevich, F. ArabatziOriginal Article, 281-291 -
Identifying Differences in Elastographic Properties of Calf Muscles and Tendons Across Subsets of Tennis Players
C. D. Sacks, R. A. Gallo, L. Kong, D. H. CortesOriginal Article, 292-300 -
Ligamentum Teres and its Analog in the Hip Endoprosthesis – Necessary or Superfluous? A Systematic Review
S. V. Arkhipov, D. V. SkvortsovReview, 301-310 -
Estimating the Dynamic Ratio of the Lateral/Medial Hamstrings. A Case Control Study
N. Malliaropoulos, G. Bikos, D. Pyne, G. Kakavas, N. Maffulli, P. TsaklisOriginal Article, 311-317 -
A 90 Minute Soccer Match Induces Eccentric Hamstring Muscles Fatigue
G. Kakavas, N. Malliaropoulos, T. Gabbett, M. Mitrotasios, N. Van Dyk, G. Bikos, N. MaffulliOriginal Article, 318-323 -
Quick Recovery and No Arthrofibrosis in Acute Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: a Prospective Trial of Early versus Delayed Reconstruction
E. Monaco, F. Iannotti, A. Carrozzo, A. Annibaldi, F. Marzilli, M. Nurzia , P. F. Indelli, A. FerrettiOriginal Article, 324-332 -
High Frequency Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation in the Immediate Postoperative Period of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction and Its Effects on Drug Costs During Hospitalization
M. B. Dohnert, N. de Oliveira Cardoso Novaski, J. Ribeiro Deves, A. Rennan de Oliveira Soares, M. Medeiros da Silveira, J. Victor Euzébio dos Santos, P. A. Kuplich, R. Boff DaitxOriginal Article, 333-339 -
Evaluation of Antifibrinolytic Use in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Arthroscopic Reconstruction. A Prospective Clinical Trial
V. La Banca, J. G. Suzuki Leal Roque, T. Protta, M. Schmidt NavarroOriginal Article, 340-343 -
Low Back Pain and Associated Factors among Italian Equestrian Athletes: a Cross-Sectional Study
M. Ferrante, F. Bonetti, F. M. Quattrini, M. Mezzetti, S. DemarieOriginal Article, 344-352 -
Most Impacting Injuries in Football: a Possible Association?
M. Glaied, G. N. Bisciotti, A. Bisciotti, A. Bisciotti, C. EiraleCase Report, 353-359 -
The Relationship between Active and Passive Flexibility of the Knee Flexors
P. Niewiadomy, K. Szuścik-Niewiadomy, M. Kochan, M. T. KuszewskiOriginal Article, 360-366